# Brand brief, audit and direction (v2)

_14 October 2026. Written from the build specification (`docs/plans/2026-10-13-pamela-woods-build-plan.md`), the repository, the v1 package and `packages/ui`. No new brand research was done for this pass, as instructed._

## 1. What existed (v1) and why it was replaced

| Item | v1 | Weakness |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Wordmark | `PAMELA WOODS` in custom monoline geometric capitals, widely spaced; option B overlaps the two O's | The letters are close to a light Futura or Avant Garde and carry no character of their own. The S is weak: two thin arcs with poor terminals. Spacing is mechanical rather than optical (the gaps around **A** and **W** are visibly uneven). The overlapping O's read as linked rings (wedding, Olympic, Audi associations), which is a cliché, not a reference to layered painting. |
| Monogram | `PW` in a heavy grotesque | Unrelated to the wordmark in weight and construction, generic ("stock monogram"), and it repeats the name rather than adding an idea. v1's own README admits it is a fallback for small sizes, not a mark. |
| Icon | None | There was nothing to use for an avatar, an app icon or a pattern seed. |
| Lowercase wordmark | None | |
| Descriptor | "Paintings, collages and photography" | No longer matches the brief, which is now **original abstract painting**. |
| Typography | System font stacks (Iowan or Palatino, plus system-ui) | Licence-free but anonymous: every device renders it differently, and nothing is ownable. |
| Palette | Ink, Paper, Graphite, Rule, Oxide | A sound neutral base, but no dark theme, no semantic roles, no UI-component contrast (WCAG 1.4.11), and only one accent. |
| Dark mode | Colourways only | No dark tokens, no adaptive favicon. |
| Favicons | ICO, 16–512 PNG, SVG | Built from the weak monogram. There was no manifest, maskable icon or head snippet, and no light/dark handling. |
| Patterns, icon set, tokens | None | |
| Build | `rsvg-convert` and ImageMagick shell-outs | Depended on locally installed system tools. Not reproducible on CI. |

**In the apps,** v1 reached the code only through `packages/ui/src/wordmark` (its path data was copied in). The app favicons were still the template defaults, not v1.

## 2. Brief

- **Who:** Pamela Woods, a contemporary abstract artist working in original abstract painting. Her work grows from a lifelong engagement with plants and the natural world. It is now expressed as abstract emotion, layered imagery, speculative landscapes and non-human forms, where the organic meets the imagined.
- **Voice:** thoughtful, intuitive, unforced, nature-connected, and resistant to fixed interpretations. Written in British English.
- **Tagline (as briefed, 14 Oct 2026; superseded):** "Original abstract paintings and artwork". The approved tagline is now "Original abstract paintings, where the organic meets the imagined" (see `README.md`); the brief's wording is kept as the fallback.
  - The alternative "Original abstract paintings, where the organic meets the imagined" was first held back because it borrows statement language that Pamela should approve. Dan approved it for the first version on 14 October 2026; Pamela's review is pending.
- **The job of the identity:** let the artwork lead. Be restrained, gallery-quality, confident and distinctive.
- **Avoid:** generic AI-logo aesthetics, clip-art leaves, paint splashes, decorative gradients and stock monograms.
- **Audiences:**
  - collectors and buyers, on the website and portfolio
  - galleries, press and open-studio visitors
  - Pamela herself, in the dashboard
- **Constraints:**
  - open-licence fonts only
  - outlined logo SVGs
  - light and dark variants
  - holds at 16 px
  - one-colour versions
  - WCAG 2.2 AA
  - no invented facts, contacts, handles or prices

## 3. Concept territories considered

1. **Signature:** typographic, personal and handwritten. Strong for a name brand, but it tends towards the stock "script monogram".
2. **Growth logic:** phyllotaxis and the golden angle, the order behind seed heads and leaf arrangement. It is honest to "plants as structure", but generates texture rather than a mark.
3. **Emergence:** one form crossing a horizon and changing state, solid above and cut away below. It holds layering, landscape and growth at once and resists a single reading.
4. **Strata:** stacked painted bands. Rejected after rendering: it read as a burger icon.
5. **Threshold:** a canvas with an organic edge. Rejected after rendering: it read as a house.

## 4. Type candidates (licence-checked)

| Family | Licence | Source | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Fraunces** (Undercase Type) | SIL OFL 1.1 | Google Fonts / Fontsource | **Chosen, primary.** Its soft, slightly wonky "Old Style" forms are organic without being quaint. The Light weight is elegant at display sizes. It has a true italic for artwork titles. |
| **Instrument Sans** (Instrument) | SIL OFL 1.1 | Google Fonts / Fontsource | **Chosen, secondary.** A neutral, contemporary grotesque. It tracks well in capitals for the uppercase wordmark and labels. |
| Instrument Serif | SIL OFL 1.1 | Google Fonts / Fontsource | Direction A. Elegant, but condensed and trend-led, with only one weight. |
| Newsreader (Production Type) | SIL OFL 1.1 | Google Fonts / Fontsource | Direction B. Excellent for text, but too neutral for a wordmark. |
| Hanken Grotesk | SIL OFL 1.1 | Google Fonts / Fontsource | Direction B. Sound, but less distinctive than Instrument Sans. |

## 5. Directions explored

Rendered boards are in `../90-build/01-directions/`:

- `direction-a-signature.png`
- `direction-b-seedhead.png`
- `direction-c-emergence.png`

| | A · Signature | B · Seedhead | C · Emergence |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Icon | `pw` italic ligature | phyllotaxis disc | seed-leaf over a horizon (inverted) |
| Wordmarks | Instrument Serif italic + Instrument Sans caps | Newsreader Light + Hanken Grotesk caps | Fraunces Light + Instrument Sans caps |
| Palette | Ink, Paper, Graphite, **Ochre**, Rule | Ink, Bone, Lichen grey, **Moss**, Rule | Ink, Paper, Stone, **Understorey**, **Clay** |
| Pattern | brush-stroke hairlines | phyllotaxis field | strata contours |
| 16 px | the monogram blurs to "pw" (acceptable, but generic) | dissolves into a grey dot (fails) | a solid block with a diagonal (holds) |
| One colour | yes | yes, but noisy | yes, by design (even-odd) |

### Recommendation: C · Emergence, with B's growth logic kept as a pattern

- **Only C passes all of the hard requirements.** It holds at 16 px, works in one colour, and serves as avatar, favicon and pattern seed, all from a single drawing.
- **The idea is native to the brief.** Organic meets imagined: a geometric ground and an organic lens. Layering: the state flips where the forms overlap. Speculative landscape: there is a horizon. Resistant to interpretation: it can be read as a leaf, a seed, a sail, a shoot or a reflection.
- **It avoids every cliché named in the brief.** It is not a clip-art leaf, because it is built from a geometric lens. There are no paint splashes, no gradients and no monogram.
- **Fraunces has organic warmth** that matches the work, and both fonts are open-licence.
- **B's phyllotaxis is too valuable to discard,** so it became the "growth" pattern.

## 6. What changed from v1, and why

| v1 | v2 | Why |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Geometric caps wordmark with linked O's | Lowercase Fraunces Light wordmark (primary) plus a tracked Instrument Sans uppercase one (secondary), both optically spaced and outlined | Warmer and more distinctive. Drops the ring cliché. Gives a lowercase form as briefed. |
| PW grotesque monogram, no icon | The Emergence icon plus a pixel-snapped micro drawing | A real mark with an idea, built for 16 px. |
| 4 colourways | light, dark, black and white for every mark | As briefed. |
| System fonts | Two OFL fonts, self-hosted woff2 with licences | Ownable, consistent across devices, legally clean. |
| 5 colours, light only | 9 semantic roles × 2 themes, with a WCAG 2.2 matrix including UI components | Supports a dark mode and accessible UI. |
| Basic favicons | Full set: adaptive SVG, fallback ICO, light and dark ICOs and PNGs, maskable, manifest, head snippet | Covers modern and legacy browsers honestly. |
| None | 83 platform icons, 3 pattern systems, tokens (JSON/CSS/Tailwind), social defaults | As briefed. |
| Shell build | Pure Node build with QA checks and determinism | Reproducible anywhere `pnpm install` works. |
